Farting in elevators (was: ImageDisk project is canceled

Roger Merchberger zmerch at 30below.com
Tue Dec 20 17:48:09 CST 2005


Rumor has it that der Mouse may have mentioned these words:
> > But it's his, to do with and to distribute as he pleases.
>
>Everybody keeps saying this as though it somehow makes it all OK.

It is.

>As I remarked in a response to Cameron Kaiser,
>
> >> [...], and after Dave said he would release the source when he was
> >> good and ready to (his right, I might add, and even though he
> >> doesn't have to justify why he wants it that way, he did),
> > His *right*, feh.
>
>Just because he has a right to do something does not mean it is a good
>thing for him to do.  (My usual example is farting in a crowded
>elevator.)

However, what if said 'farter' had a heart condition that was detrimental 
to one's health (including the possibility of death) if he/she *did not 
fart* to relieve the pressure?

Yes, this exists, yes, *I've Had It*, and yes, despite the fact that I was 
exceptionally apologetic, no-one seemed to believe my "excuse" of "doctor's 
orders."

And - Dave's software and his personal choice to do with as he pleases has 
absolutely nothing to do with the release of methane in tight spaces.

> > The SOB who does the work gets to choose what he does with it.
>
>Certainly.  And everyone else gets to think more or less of him for it.
>As far as I can recall, the only thing I said that was critical of Dave
>was that his distribution policy took him down a few notches in my
>eyes.  (Well, before he got mad about it, at least; since then I have
>criticized the way he reacted too.)

I see the argument that it's OK to think less of a person due to his 
personal preference of software release no less ridiculous than to think 
less of a person due to their personal preference of religion.

'Nuff Said.

Regards,
Roger Merchberger

--
Roger Merchberger           | A new truth in advertising slogan
SysAdmin, Iceberg Computers | for MicroSoft: "We're not the oxy...
zmerch at 30below.com          |                         ...in oxymoron!"



More information about the cctalk mailing list